Why AEO gains come from existing pages
The cheapest AEO wins are hiding in pages that already rank between positions two and eight. Those pages have already cleared the hard part - retrieval, authority, topical relevance - and are losing only the selection step. Selection is decided by paragraph shape, not by domain strength, so the work is editorial and can be finished in an afternoon per page rather than in a quarter-long link campaign.
A useful way to find them is to sort Search Console queries by impressions, filter to positions under nine, and flag anything with a click-through rate below roughly a third of the typical curve for that position. The gap between expected and actual clicks is the value an answer surface is currently intercepting. Add up those missing clicks across a site and the number is usually larger than anything a new-content plan would produce in the same period.
Once you have the list, work query by query rather than page by page. A single page often loses three or four different question queries for three different structural reasons, and fixing them individually is faster than attempting a full rewrite that risks the ranking you already hold.
The mechanics of a passage that gets selected
Selected passages share a recognizable shape: a heading that restates the question in the user's words, a first sentence that answers it outright, a second and third sentence that add the qualifying detail, and then a stop. No preamble about why the topic matters, no promise that the answer is coming later, no dependency on a definition given two sections earlier.
Specificity carries disproportionate weight because it is a proxy for verifiability. 'Most sites see improvement within a few weeks' is unquotable; 'pages typically regain snippet ownership within one to three crawl cycles, usually seven to twenty-one days' is quotable, because it commits to something a system can attribute to you rather than to the general consensus.
The last mechanical detail is redundancy of context. Because the block will be read outside the page, it must name its own subject. Replace 'it', 'this approach', and 'the tool' with the actual noun at least once per block. This reads slightly repetitively to a human scanning the whole page and reads perfectly to anyone who sees only the extracted paragraph - which is now the larger audience.